Batgirl (USA) di C.Stewart & B.Fletcher

[Azrael]

PREVIEW: BATGIRL #52



http://www.comicbookresources.com/comic-previews/batgirl-52-dc-comics-2016

[Azrael]

Batgirl #52 (Published by DC Comics; Review by Vanessa Gabriel; 'Rama Rating: 5 out of 10):

Batgirl #52 succeeds with an authentic tone and emotional farewells with those closest to her as Babs moves on to the next stage of her life. But the semantic execution of the issue leaves a lot to be desired. The panels are packed too full as Babs, Black Canary, Blue Bird and Vixen manage to tie up the loose-end of Gladius in a most Saturday morning cartoon kind of way. That resolution feels wholly unimaginative. The few endearing character moments for the girls of Gotham Academy don't make up for the amount of errors in spelling and grammar, and the panels of faulty costume coloring that rushed Batgirl #52 to print. As the "New 52" is winds down, this closing issue of a defining and innovative run for Batgirl doesn't quite do the book justice.

[Azrael]

I don't know how directly involved Brenden Fletcher is in the process of deciding which artists will draw his DC books, but every single one of those books just look great. Eleanor Carlini picks up her art duties where they left off from last issue's fun adventure. It's impressive to see that the book can still dazzle in many of the same ways that it did earlier in its run, even with the loss of all-star artist Babs Tarr. Even more impressively, the artist changes halfway through the issue, but this book is able to avoid the recent DC curse of "two mismatched artists". Minkyu Jung is a wonderful complement to Carlini and a quirky fun artist in his own right. We'll miss this run of Batgirl and hope the book will be able to keep up this artistic consistency post-Rebirth. - Levi

Final Score:

7.8/10

IGN

[Azrael]

BATGIRL #52

3/5

http://www.comicbookresources.com/comic-review/batgirl-52-dc-comics

[Azrael]

Review: BATGIRL Volume 3: MINDFIELDS



9/10

http://www.comicosity.com/review-batgirl-volume-3-mindfields/